Carbs Are Not Created Equal
TRUE OR FALSE?
Eating cold cereal may be bad for your heart.
True.
Popular
cereal brands may feature claims on their packaging about how
beneficial their products are for heart health. They get away with this
because manufacturers focus consumer attention on studies about
fiber—which is good for the heart. They then portray themselves as
being concerned with health, even though the fiber in their product has
been so thoroughly processed that it’s rendered useless. More
importantly, their product has a number of negatives that they neglect
to tell us about.
Advertisers fail to
mention that eating highly processed cereal is like pouring table sugar
down your throat. This stimulates insulin spikes that over time can
contribute to insulin resistance, obesity, and an increased risk of
diabetes. Most people know about the damage diabetes can do—damage that
may lead to amputation, blindness, and heart trouble. So how have the
advertising companies convinced us that eating a bowl of their
formulated sugar is healthy?
Advertisers fail to mention that eating highly processed cereal is like pouring table sugar down your throat.
This isn’t to say that all marketers are liars or all companies are out to sell you harmful products. But it is true that you can’t always believe what you read. Educate yourself and pay attention to ingredients—not flashy claims.
Can’t Get No Satisfaction
Have
you ever been short on time and grabbed a donut for breakfast in the
morning on your way to work? How did you feel an hour or so later?
Chances are you felt pretty low on energy. What did you crave to eat later in the day?
Most
likely, you wanted more sweet carbs. When we eat processed
foods—especially flour—the body is being set up. Our bodies absorb
these calories very quickly—much too quickly, in fact. The result is a
physiological reaction that makes our body crave more. It’s similar to
having an addiction.
Many of us grew up with the food pyramid. It was probably one of the earliest lessons we learned about nutrition. Now we must unlearn what we memorized from cereal boxes, bread sacks, and school lunchroom posters. We should, in fact, not
be consuming eight to eleven servings of what we then believed were
healthy grains, as most of them were bleached and devoid of any
nutritional value.
Many of our nation’s most
popular foods are dangerous because they are highly processed, made
with refined flour that comes from highspeed rolling mills that
replaced the traditional millstones of the eighteenth century. The new
mills became faster and most efficient after the discovery of
degermination, a process that took the grain and removed the seed
coat—called the bran—and the germ, which is the embryo of the seed that
is an integral part of whole-grain foods. It also stripped the flour of
a lot of its nutritional value because the bran is where the fiber, B
vitamins, and trace minerals are, and the germ contains antioxidants
and vitamins B and E.
The impact of this one
process forever changed the course of American history, as rarely does
an American family go a day without eating bread.
The
result of the new milling process was a superfine, pure white flour
that does not spoil. How could it get any better for bakers? Not only
are the breads and pastries they make from this flour light and tasty,
but they also have an extra-long shelf life.
Unfortunately,
the results have been less than ideal for those of us who are eating
these long-lasting foods. The body is able to absorb the glucose from
the superfine particles of white or wheat flour so quickly that it
results in a rapid rise of our blood sugar—worse than would occur if
you were eating a candy bar. (If only you’d known for all these years
that a Snickers® bar would have been better for you than white toast for breakfast!)
And
as you know, what goes up must come down. The rapid rise in blood sugar
is followed by a rapid fall after a surge of insulin is released to
store that sugar in your fat, leaving your fat cells plump and you
feeling sluggish. As if that weren’t bad enough, you’ll also have a
seemingly uncontrollable craving for more sweets to help get your blood sugar level back in balance.
We
are now beginning to realize that our love of pastries and white bread
is central to the epidemic of obesity, diabetes, and other inflammatory
diseases we see in the world today. Repeatedly eating foods that spike
our blood sugar—otherwise known as foods with a high glycemic
index—makes us gain weight and, over time, causes lasting damage to our
health.
Breaking Bread
Much of the
bread you find in supermarkets contains more than flour—much more. Just
compare the simple ingredients of good, old-fashioned homemade bread
with the ingredients list of the white bread you buy in the store.
Homemade Bread:
Whole-wheat flour, sugar, salt, yeast, milk, butter, and water.
Store-bought White Bread:
Enriched wheat flour, water, wheat gluten, high
fructose corn syrup, soybean oil, salt, molasses, yeast, mono and
diglycerides, exthoxylated mono and diglycerides, dough conditioners
(sodium stearoyl lactylate, calcium iodate, calcium dioxide), datem,
calcium sulfate, vinegar, yeast nutrient (ammonium sulfate), extracts
of malted barley and corn, dicalcium phosphate, diammonium phosphate,
and calcium propionate (to retain freshness).
The Glycemic Index
First
introduced by Dr. David J. Jenkins in 1981, the glycemic index has
become a household term. Jenkins defined the glycemic index as the rate
blood sugar rises after eating a particular test food, relative to that
of a control food—usually glucose.
When the
glycemic index was first released, most dieticians, nutritionists, and
physicians were shocked by the results; it flew in the face of
long-held assumptions that complex carbohydrates are always better than
simple carbohydrates, and that all calories are created equal.
As
an example of this new thinking, simple sugars such as table
sugar—sucrose—have a glycemic index value of 61, while the sugar found
in fruits—fructose—has a much-preferred glycemic index value of only
19. Thus, many of our “healthy” breakfast cereals, such as corn flakes,
bran flakes, and oat rings top out the glycemic index, some scoring as
high as 92. Suddenly those plastic baggies full of Cheerios® for kids don’t seem like such a great snack, unless you want your kids to be chubby enough to stay warm in the winter.
To
get an even truer view of your response to a particular food, you’d
need to calculate the glycemic load. Glycemic load takes into account
the glycemic index and the concentration of carbohydrates. Low
is 10 or less, medium is 11–19, and 20 or greater is considered high.
For example, cooked carrots have a medium glycemic index of 49, whereas
their glycemic load is a very low 2.4 because there are few
carbohydrates in carrots. This means that eating carrots won’t tend to
spike your blood sugar. However, potatoes have both a high glycemic
index and a high glycemic load, which will significantly raise the blood sugar and stimulate a heightened insulin response.
Glycemic Index of Selected Foods
Cereals | GI |
---|
Shredded wheat | 67 |
Raisin bran | 73 |
Oat rings | 74 |
Corn flakes | 83 |
Fruit |
|
Apple | 38 |
Orange | 43 |
Raisins | 64 |
Dates | 103 |
Snacks |
|
Chocolate bar | 49 |
Potato chips | 56 |
Doughnut | 76 |
Jelly beans | 80 |
Vegetables |
|
Yam | 54 |
Sweet corn | 56 |
French fries | 75 |
Baked red potato | 93 |
Breads |
|
Rye | 64 |
Wheat | 68 |
White | 70 |
Bagel, plain | 72 |
Legumes |
|
Soy beans, boiled | 16 |
Kidney beans, canned | 29 |
Lima beans, boiled | 32 |
Baked beans | 45 |
One
of the best ways to avoid high-glycemic carbs is to eat fresh fruits
and vegetables deep in color—these are also typically richer in
antioxidants. Whole foods that grow close to the ground are packed with
living vitamins, minerals, water, fiber, and the enzymes needed to
digest the food itself. They are the perfect fit for the cells of our
bodies and for nurturing the body in just the right balance.
Thousands of studies have proven that
fruits and vegetables are excellent sources of important phytochemicals
that are beneficial for fighting disease.
Beyond
fruits and vegetables, you can gain control of the glycemic load of
your diet by reducing your intake of refined sugars and starches,
eating fiberrich foods, and consuming balanced meals containing protein
and fat along with carbohydrates.
Simple Solution:
Garden produce in a rainbow of colors will
help you maintain a low-glycemic, nutrient-rich diet. The deeper the
color, the better.