Sometimes negative thinking is more than a passing
emotion and becomes a more pervasive mood. Cognitive restructuring will
help you to challenge your negative moods and change the thinking that
lies behind them.
Turn Your Mood Around
Negative moods are not
only unpleasant – they reduce the quality of your performance and
undermine your working and social relationships. Cognitive restructuring
can help you to turn these moods around so that you can approach
situations in a more positive frame of mind. The principle behind this
technique is that our moods are driven by what we tell ourselves, and
that this, in turn, is based on our interpretation of our environment.
Case Study: Managing Unhappy Moods
Melinda had been
feeling unhappy for weeks. She’d had a big argument with Alicia, one of
her best friends at her new job. Having good friends at work was
important to her, and she was feeling miserable and insecure. She spoke
about this to her partner who suggested that she should analyze why she
was feeling as she did.
Identifying her dominant mood
as “rejected”, her thoughts were, “she doesn’t like me any more, and,
“she doesn’t think I’m good enough to be her friend.” As supporting
evidence, she cited the aggression and anger she’d faced from Alicia.
However, thinking about the opposing evidence, she remembered that
Alicia had seemed quite shame-faced after the argument and had seemed to
want to talk, but hadn’t. She also remembered that she had been having
family problems.
Taking a
balanced view, Melinda realized that Alicia’s personal problems had
spilled over into her working life and were having an effect on their
relationship.
Melinda resolved
to be warm and friendly the next day and to talk through any problems.
Alicia’s friendship with her was soon back on track.
Cognitive Restructuring
Cognitive restructuring is a
useful technique to use when you identify that you are in an unhappy
mood. This might be when you are sad, angry, anxious, upset, or in one
of many other negative states of mind. It can also be used if you note
that you are frequently experiencing bad moods of a particular type or
in particular circumstances.
What Triggered Your Mood?
When you are aware that
you have experienced a negative mood, record the details of the event
or situation that has triggered it.
Example
You may have been in a
meeting with other members of your team when your manager rejected, out
of hand, a suggestion that you made.
What Was Your Mood?
Identify the deep feelings
that you had. Moods are not thoughts. Moods can usually be expressed in
one word, while thoughts are more complex. You may have felt several
different moods at the same time. .
Example
For example, “He is
trashing my suggestion in front of my co-workers,” would be a thought,
while the associated moods might be “humiliation”, “frustration”,
“anger”, or “insecurity”.
Change the Way You Think
Where issues are
difficult and important and require a careful, considered examination,
cognitive restructuring enables you to examine how rational and valid
your interpretations are, and, if appropriate, to test them. Where you
find that your interpretations of a situation are incorrect, this will
naturally change the way you think about that situation and will change
your mood. If you find that you frequently experience a negative mood in
response to events, it is worth taking the time to learn the technique
of cognitive restructuring.
Tip
If unhappy moods persist and you feel that you may
be becoming depressed, it is important that you see a doctor for advice.
Write Down Your Automatic Thoughts
Begin the restructuring
process by writing down the particular thoughts that spring into your
mind when you feel unhappy. For example:
Everyone will think badly of me
Maybe my analysis skills aren’t good enough
How rude and arrogant of him!
This is undermining my future with this organization
Identify the most
distressing of these – the “hot thoughts”. In this case, the first two
thoughts might be regarded as the hot thoughts.
Note Supporting and Contradictory Evidence
Identify the objective
evidence that supports these hot thoughts. If you are in a meeting, for
example, you might write down that the discussion moved on without any
account being taken of your suggestion, and that your boss did identify a
flaw in one of the arguments in your paper on the subject.
Next, identify the
objective evidence that does not support the hot thoughts. You might
write down that the flaw in your argument was minor and didn’t alter the
conclusions reached, that your analysis was objectively sound, that the
suggestion was well founded, and that your clients respect your
analysis and opinions.
Deal with Hot Thoughts
High Impact
Understanding your moods
Taking a serious approach to your unhappy moods
Understanding what lies behind your moods
Evaluating supporting and opposing evidence
Taking positive action
Negative Impact
Getting stuck in a cycle of negative thinking
Not seeing hot thoughts as being of importance
Experiencing without analyzing
Accepting negative thinking without thought
Letting bad situations persist
Techniques to Practise
The cognitive restructuring technique consists of a seven-step process.
Record your findings at each stage by writing them on a sheet of paper divided into seven columns.
Write down details of the situation that triggered the negative thoughts.
Identify the moods that you experienced while you were in the situation.
Write down the immediate distressing thoughts that you experienced when you felt the negative mood.
Identify the evidence that exists to supports these “hot thoughts”.
Identify the evidence that contradicts the hot thoughts.
Identify fair, balanced thoughts about the situation.
Observe your mood and think about what you’ll do.
Look at Both Sides
It’s important to look at
the situation objectively. If there are still substantial points of
uncertainty, discuss the situation with other people who have a view.
The balanced thoughts in the meeting example might now be: “Other people
respect my abilities. My analysis was reasonable, but not perfect.
There was an error, but the conclusions were valid. People were shocked
by the way he handled my suggestion.”
Decide What You’re Going to Do
NOTE
A fair analysis is likely to produce a fair solution
Finally, observe your mood
now and think about what action you are going to take. Hopefully your
mood has improved. You should now have a clearer view of the situation.
You may conclude that no action is appropriate. By looking at the
situation in a balanced way, it may cease to be important.