by Jessica Forsyth
photos By Ed Olen
With miles of coastline, beach cities stretching from Huntington Beach down
to San Clemente and more palm trees than most tropical islands, it can be easy
to forget that Orange County’s culture, while firmly rooted in white sand and ocean
views, can also mean cityscapes, art communities and yes, even inland
destinations. One such location is Santa Ana’s Artist’s Village, a few square
blocks carved out of OC’s second most populous city, where art, music and food
have become the central stage for cultivating the city’s evolution into a
center for culture. And yet, while small in physical area, one gets the feeling
of being in a real city for a square block or two, watching artists fling paint
on canvases through lit windows and diners linger on patios strung with lights,
discussing (we imagine) things like literature and politics. Of course, it
helps to have venues at which to pursue these lofty intellectual ideals, and Chapter
One: The Modern Local, is the newest arrival on the culinary scene to
facilitate OC’s passage into citified greatness.
The first thing one notices upon arrival at Chapter One is not the food
– though that is undoubtedly prominent – but rather the lengthy bar and shelves
lined with books – a tribute, no doubt, to the restaurant’s name, but also an
indication of the kind of place that Chapter One is striving to become. One
part restaurant, one part gastropub and one part “modern local,” it lands somewhere
between community gathering place and foodie destination, with a wisely edited
culinary cocktail menu and food choices ranging from the bite-sized (Scotch eggs)
to the man-sized (Italian burger with portabella) and the low-brow (Asian
chicken wings) to the high-brow (seared duck breast with sweet potato waffle).
To be sure, there’s something for everyone – including playful spins on
desserts of which we’ve refreshingly never heard (chocolate soil with fried
wontons, anyone?).
We kicked off this experimental feast with one of the specials for the
evening: grilled baby octopus salad with mixed baby greens, shaved fresh
fennel, tomatoes, capers, red onions, scallions, and feta
cheese and topped with a roasted lemon vinaigrette. Fresh and
sophisticated, the salad was delightfully light with gently accented citrus
flavors, which all came together with the concentrated zing of a balsamic
vinegar reduction. On the opposite side of the spectrum was the potato pear, a
gastronomical riddle that revealed itself to be a pear-shaped riced potato
stuffed with mushroom duxelle, breaded and then surrounded by a puddle of wild
mushroom- Marsala cream sauce. We had high hopes for this dish, not entirely
because of its mysterious name, but the final result lacked a bit in the flavor
department. Even when infused with the mushroom duxelle, the potato pear was
lackluster, and the cream sauce, while silky smooth in texture, could have used
more of an infusion of both mushroom and Marsala.
True to casual-meets-fine dining fare, Chapter One’s sandwich selection
is as it should be: diverse. We tried the island pulled pork sandwich, which
ranked somewhere between a sloppy Joe and traditional pulled pork. While the
pork mixture could have been a bit firmer, the addition of IPA beer to the marinade
gave a welcome depth of flavor and cabbage provided crunchy texture. An acorn squash
aioli was a little lost amongst already strong components and the shoestring
fries, while crispy, could have used a bit more of a soft center to round them
out.
The larger plates on the menu are where Chapter One seemed to hit its
stride with dishes like the beef culotte (the top cut off of a top sirloin),
which is bacon-wrapped, crusted with coffee and chocolate and served with Dijon
mashed potatoes. Extremely tender, with subtle aromas of earthy chocolate and
coffee coming through, the steak was undoubtedly one of the highlights of
Chapter One’s menu. The mac and cheese with white cheddar, fontina, pearl
onions, smokey bacon, fried onions, and toasted panko was similarly flawless.
Sharp cheese flavors managed to cut through al dente macaroni, and aromas of
bacon and the crunch of fried onions and toasted panko rounded out what we’ve determined
to be amongst the best mac and cheeses in the OC.
Yet, for all the innovation on Chapter One’s menu, it’s the desserts
that leave the final taste of the restaurant – and it’s a good one. Whiskey and
Coke consisted of black pepper sponge cake with whiskey ice cream, Coke foam,
unconched chocolate, and chocolate oil – a tried-and-true amalgamation of
flavors, yet never before presented in such a successful dessert rendition.
Milk and Cereal (translation: vanilla panna cotta, kataifi, Cinnamon Toast
Crunch ice cream, seasonal fruit, and fresh juice caviar pearls) was as
beautiful as it was delicious with edible flower petals draped over a creamy white
concoction that tasted like a grown-up version of cereal-laced milk.
Part edible intellectualism and part exploration of uncharted culinary
frontiers, Chapter One gives us the feeling that there are more vignettes to
come. We certainly hope so.
Whiskey and Coke – black pepper sponge cake,
whiskey ice cream, Coke foam, unconched chocolate, and chocolate oil
Taking the book theme seriously, Chapter One’s shelves
are lined with literature
Octopus salad
milk and Cereal – vanilla panna cotta, kataifi,
Cinnamon toast Crunch ice cream, seasonal fruit, and fresh juice caviar pearls
“potato pear,” made of riced potato and stuffed
with mushroom duxelle, breaded and doused in wild mushroom marsala cream sauce
Baconwrapped coffee- and chocolate-crusted beef
culotte with dijon mashed potatoes
Mac and cheese with white cheddar and fontina, pearl
onions, smokey bacon, fried onions, and toasted panko