It costs the same as IVF but, rather than giving you just one shot at conceiving, a radical new treatment claims to rewind your fertility. We investigate the controversial technique coming this year.

Ten years ago, egg freezing seemed like a sci-fi fantasy come true. Now, a new fertility treatment makes it look positively passé. Why freeze a few eggs when having sections of your ovarian tissue removed and put on ice could give you up to 60,000 eggs long after your body would have stopped producing them naturally?

Almost half of young women are delaying motherhood because they don't want to give up their freedom, a new survey has revealed.

Almost half of young women are delaying motherhood because they don't want to give up their freedom, a new survey has revealed.

Until now, ovarian tissue freezing (OTF) has only been conducted in a handful of countries, including Denmark and the US, and has been restricted to cancer patients receiving chemotherapy. But such is the buzz surrounding in that, this year, fertility consultant Dr Gedis Grudzinskas (grudzinskas.co.uk) is set to open a London clinic dedicated to the treatment. ‘Fertility preservation is an incredibly exciting field right now,’ he says. And though OTF is a relatively new procedure, 28 babies have been born as a result of it. Some expert believe it has the potential to become more popular and successful than egg freezing and even IVF - in fact, it costs about $24,000, not far off the cost of the average three cycles of IVF most couples need to conceive.

It involves removing tissue from one ovary under general anaesthetic, and then freezing it thus stopping the clock to perverse the health of your egg stores, which would otherwise deteriorate over time. The frozen tissue can then be thawed out and re-implanted into the body to take up where it left off when conception is desired. Successful pregnancies have occurred up to seven years after freezing.

‘Freezing ovarian tissue is suitable for cancer patients’, says Dr Geetha Venkat, founder of the Harley Street Fertility Clinic (hsfc.org.uk). ‘Unlike egg freezing, which can take around eight weeks of hormone therapy to harvest around 10 eggs OFT can be performed quickly, so as not to delay cancer treatment.’ But it’s not just cancer patients who’ll want to sign up for OTF. ‘It may also be suitable for women who have benign ovarian disease, such as endometriosis,’ explains Dr Grudzinskas, ‘or other issues that put them at risk of early menopause.’ But by far the fastest growing group seeking fertility preservation, he claims, is healthy women who want to delay motherhood. ‘We’re definitely seeing more women who have postponed having babies for their career, he says. But Dr Gillian Lockwood, spokesperson for the British Fertility Soceity and Medical Director at Midland Fertility Services (midlandfertility.com) is keen to make a distinction. ‘Yes, there are more women seeking fertility preservation for lifestyle reasons,’ she says. ‘But it’s not simply a case of them being so busy in the boardroom they “forgot” to have children. Most just haven’t met Mr Right or did, but he turned out to be Mr Wrong’.

‘Freezing ovarian tissue is suitable for cancer patients’

‘Freezing ovarian tissue is suitable for cancer patients’

New science

But while there’s demand for ovarian freezing, it’s still in its infancy. ‘This is largely an experimental treatment,’ points out Dr Lockwood. Dr Venkat agrees: ‘It’s ideal for cancer patients who risk losing their fertility post treatment anyway, or women who are already sub fertile,’ she says, ‘but, for healthy women, other, less invasive options, such as egg harvesting, might be more suitable. After all, surgery isn’t without risk. Healthy ovarian tissue could become damaged, compromising your fertility.’

Dr Grudzinskas dismisses the dangers. ‘If it’s peformed by a team of top anesthesiologists, cell biologists and leading Gynaecologists, the risks are minimal.’ He cites Denmark, the leader in the ovarian freezing field, as a model for best practice. ‘Anyone can freeze ovarian tissue getting it right is the real challenge.’ Indeed, none of the babies born from ovarian tissue freezing have been delivered in the UK. ‘This is the real measure of success,’ points out Dr Lockwood. ‘Compare that with egg freezing, where hundreds of healthy babies have been born and I know which I’d rather spend my money on.’

Cost, of course, is a consideration. While egg freezing will set you back $7500, OTF costs over three times as much. But, as Dr Grudzinskas says, conception should be able to occur naturally after the ovarian tissue is re-implanted (ovulation starts within months, as the follicles mature naturally) so, unlike IVF, there’d be no further costs if you wanted more children. In fact, one Danish former cancer patient has had three children naturally, after OTF. Plus, as with any increasingly popular therapy, the price is likely to fall as demand rises, which it looks set to do now the academics appear to have given it the green light. A recent review of OTF in the Journal of Molecular Human Reproduction concluded that the results to date were encouraging enough to suggest the treatment ‘might be ready for consideration by women without cancer who must delay childbearing for other reasons.’

Egg freezing offers women the opportunity to preserve their fertility and take control of their reproductive health.

Egg freezing offers women the opportunity to preserve their fertility and take control of their reproductive health.

Safety first

However, other experts including the IVF pioneer Lord Robert Winston have expressed concerns about the safety of the procedure for the baby, in particular that there’s simply not enough research to know the long term effects of freezing ovarian tissue. Winston has been equally outspoken on the exploitation of desperate women, describing egg freezing as ‘a giant confidence trick’ and recommending that it should be limited to those require it for medical reasons. As far as the NHS is concerned, a NICE report on freezing and re-implanting says the practicalities need to be developed further.

Dr Grudzinskas remains undeterred. ‘Isn’t that what people once said about frozen embryos? Purists always object when medicine is hijacked by lifestyle choices. But this is the reality for many women,’ he says. ‘Besides, we’re not just talking about babies OTF could potentially offer a natural alternative to HRT. Women would simply bank tissue in their twenties and have sections re-implanted as they approach menopause, so their hormone levels never run low. It’s a whole new chapter in regenerative medicine.’

Do other experts see a time when women routinely bank tissue in this way? ‘Certainly their eggs,’ says Dr Lockwood. ‘But it does worry me that women will view this as an insurance policy and miss out on the chance to have babies naturally. It really should be seen as a back-up plan and not a first choice.’

Dr Venkat would like to see us all being more proactive. ‘Fertility MOT’s every three years from the age of 25 should become as routine as smear tests,’ she says. ‘That way, if you do have a fertility issue, you can act before it’s too late.’ Even Dr Grudzinskas isn’t afraid to put himself out of a job. ‘Let’s be clear’, he says, ‘women who want children would be best having them in their twenties. But the fact is society isn’t set up like that anymore and, as long as there’s demand, we should continue to develop the technology and offer hope to as many women as we can.’ The future, it seems, is on ice.

Top search
- 6 Ways To Have a Natural Miscarriage
- Foods That Cause Miscarriage
- Losing Weight In A Week With Honey
- Can You Eat Crab Meat During Pregnancy?
- Grape Is Pregnant Women’s Friend
- 4 Kinds Of Fruit That Can Increase Risk Of Miscarriage
- Some Drinks Pregnant Women Should Say No With
- Signs Proving You Have Boy Pregnancy
- Why Do Pregnant Women Have Stomachache When Eating?
- Top Foods That Pregnant Women Should Be Careful Of
- 6 Kinds Of Vegetable That Increase Risk Of Miscarriage
- It's All About Me! MyPyramid (part 3) : Food Intake Patterns, Build a Healthy Nutrition Base
- It's All About Me! MyPyramid (part 2) : Choose Sensibly
- It's All About Me! MyPyramid (part 1) : Build a Healthy Nutrition Base!
- 9 WEEKS PREGNANT : Banish Paper Pile-Ups
- 8 WEEKS PREGNANT : Understand and Control the Exhaustion
- Are Your Postcode Making You ill? (Part 2)
- Are Your Postcode Making You ill? (Part 1)
- 50 Shades Of Blue (Part 2)
- 50 Shades Of Blue (Part 1)
- Preparing for Pregnancy (part 4) : Be Careful with Vitamins, Minerals and Herbs, Substance Use before Pregnancy, Work and Pregnancy
Top keywords
Miscarriage Pregnant Pregnancy Pregnancy day by day Pregnancy week by week Losing Weight Stress Placenta Makeup Collection
Top 5
- 5 Ways to Support Your Baby Development
- 5 Tips for Safe Exercise During Pregnancy
- Four Natural Ways Alternative Medicine Can Help You Get Pregnant (part 2)
- Four Natural Ways Alternative Medicine Can Help You Get Pregnant (part 1)
- Is Your Mental Health Causing You to Gain Weight (part 2) - Bipolar Disorder Associated with Weight Gain